The Life Cycle of Investigations Series – Part 2: Commencing an Investigation and Deciding Who Will Conduct It

Knowledge

Our second article in our series “The Life Cycle of Investigations” examines the process employers should follow prior to commencing an investigation, and the considerations they should take into account when choosing who to engage as an external investigator.

Commencing an Investigation

When an employer is considering disciplinary action, they must first make appropriate enquiries and determine the facts giving rise to the alleged conduct. This is typically done through an investigation.

Investigations vary in complexity. Some are relatively straightforward while others may involve reviewing documents and data, interviewing witnesses, and assessing the relevant evidence. An investigator will usually only make factual findings, however sometimes they will also be asked to determine whether the employee has breached the required standards of conduct.

Therefore, at the outset of the investigation, it is important to clearly define:

Timing can present challenges. An employer must have sufficient information to justify commencing an investigation but should avoid conducting a full investigation before notifying the employee. Generally, once an allegation has been made, the employee should be advised that a formal investigation will proceed in relation to it. In some situations, for example, where there are safety concerns or a risk that evidence may be altered or destroyed, preliminary steps may need to be taken to address these before liaising with the employee.

Choosing an Investigator

If the matter is straightforward, the investigation may be conducted internally, including by the decision-maker or another independent person. More complex matters are often referred to an external investigator, with the process and scope clearly defined in Terms of Reference. These Terms of Reference should be prepared in consultation with the employee whose conduct is the subject of the investigation.

There is no strict requirement to appoint an independent investigator (that is, someone other than the decision maker who will make the final decision). However, if an independent investigator is going to be used, they need to be independent, free from bias, and therefore consider all relevant information in a balanced and objective way. This does not require complete detachment or an absence of prior dealings with the employee. Rather, the investigator must be capable of acting objectively and professionally so that there is no real risk of bias. This is why engaging another manager, Human Resources, or an external investigator to gather and present the facts in an impartial manner is often beneficial.

An independent investigator must also be familiar with and follow the procedural requirements of natural justice.

Employers should ensure the investigator has the capacity to complete the investigation within a reasonable timeframe. Any delays or procedural deficiencies in the investigation process will be attributed to the employer.

If an organisation chooses to use an external independent investigator, they should be aware of the regulatory requirements for investigators which provide that they must be carried out by either a lawyer holding a practising certificate or a private investigator licensed under the Private Security Personnel and Private Investigators Act 2010.

If you would like assistance in preparing for or undertaking an investigation, please contact the team at Black Door Law.

Investigations vs. Workplace Reviews

Finally, an investigation should not be confused with a workplace review. An employment investigation is usually a formal fact-finding process focused on specific allegations concerning identified employees and may result in disciplinary action. A review, by contrast, is broader and systemic. It typically examines workplace culture, systems, or organisational issues rather than individual fault. Reviews may be prompted by patterns of complaints, cultural concerns, high staff turnover, or other organisation-wide issues. While we are happy to advise on or conduct workplace reviews, they are beyond the scope of this series.

Up next: Stay tuned for our third article in The Life Cycle of Investigations series, which explains the importance of including Terms of Reference in an investigation, and determining what process should be followed.

Disclaimer: This information is intended as general legal information and does not constitute legal advice. If you have a specific issue and wish to discuss it, get in touch with the Black Door Law team by email hello@blackdoorlaw.co.nz or calling (04) 280 3980.